ACUPUNCTURE THESIS
THE FIFTH WORLD CONFERENCE ON ACUPUNCTURE
KS-0102 LOCATION SEOUL
TITLE: Functional Neuroimaging
and Acupuncture
ISSUE DATE: November 12-15,
2000
LAST NAME: Jie-guang
NAME: Sun
NATIONALITY: Hong Kong
ADDRESS: Rm204, 2/F, chow yei ching Bldg, The University of HK.
ABSTRACT: abbreviation
B-1.
TITLE: Functional Neuroimaging and Acupuncture
AUTHOR(S): JG SUN, V Wong, ES Yang, QY Ma
ABSTRACT:
Introduction: Acupuncture is a treatment technique developed by
practitioners of Traditional Chinese Medicine(TCM) thousands of
years ago and has been performed in China for a long time. The method
of healing is to promote recovery using the body's homeostatic systems
by needling specific anatomical sites on the body surface. Tongue
Acupuncture (TA) is a new technique developed by Sun JG that shared
the same theory of traditional acupuncture. It is done by needling
specific site on the tongue instead of the body surface.
Functional neuroimaging techniques have been used to study the biophysical
and biochemical processes of human brain for many decades. Among
them, positron emission tomography (PET) and functional magnetic
resonance imaging (fMRI) techniques are widely used in neuroscience
community as the major non-invasive tools to study human brain functions.
PET is favorable for its quantitative results while fMRI provides
high spatial and temporal resolution images and could readily incorporated
in current clinical system. In our studies, fMRI was used as an
index of brain function to study the neuronal recovery of brain-disordered
patients after tongue acupuncture. 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG)
PET was used to study the change in glucose metabolism during acupuncture
procedure. We have demonstrated, for the first time, that tongue
acupuncture would increase glucoses metabolism and would effect
on brain plasticity. This study has also proven that the advanced
functional neuroimaging techniques could be directly applied to
the studying, monitoring, and verification of the acupuncture treatment
process.
Methods: In 1999 April-2000 August, we recruited patients with neurological
diseases whose disabilities had been static with conventional Western
treatment for TAC treatment. The outcome was assessed objectively
with clinical, functional, and neuroimaging (fMRI/PET) modalities.
Results:[1] Stroke Project [N=25] adults with stable stroke for
>2 years (4 weeks twice daily TAC) - There was statistically
significant improvement in the following measures: National Institute
of Health Stroke Scale (p<0.0001), Edinburgh Stroke Scale (p<0.0014),
hemiplegic hand muscle power with dynamometer (p<0.0001), Barthel's
Activities of daily Living index (p<0.05) and modified Rankin
Scale 9p<0.05). fMRI showed reactivation of the contralateral
hand motor cortex in some.
[2] Cerebral Palsy Project [N=15](8 weeks daily TAC) - There was
statisticaly significant improvement in functional independence
measure of children (p<0.05). fMRI showed reactivation of contralateral
hand motor cortex in hemiplegia, and reactivation of feet motor
cortex in spastic diplegia.
[3] Cortical Visual Impairment Project [N=5] (consecutive daily
TAC for 40-120 weeks) - There was improvement in visual acuity,
functional level of vision, visual evoked potential. FMRI showed
reactivation of visual cortex in 2 patients. [4] PET Project: More
than 20% activation of the superior temporal gyrus (auditory cortex)
and calcarine /precuneus gyrus in occipital lobes (visual cortex)
were detected in 2 healthy subjects after 3 daily TAC treatment.
The activation was statistically more significant with real time
electrical TAC in addition to TAC.
Discussion: Our study had demonstrated the efficacy of TAC in improving
neurological disabilities. Objective evidence of brain plasticity
was demonstrated even in aged patients with stable stroke. Even
children with cortical blindness of 5-14 years duration had shown
partial recovery of visual function, though with intensive courses
of treatment.
Conclusion: Functional Neuroimaging techniques are useful in objectively
demonstrating brain plasticity with TAC. The quantification of glucose
activation in the brain with repeated TAC courses in patients should
be evaluated along with clinical parameters.
Keywords: tongue acupuncture, fMRI, PET, stroke, cerebral palsy,
cortical visual impairment
ACUPUNCTURE THESIS
THE FIFTH WORLD CONFERENCE ON ACUPUNCTURE
KS-0103 LOCATION SEOUL
TITLE: CLINIC STUDY OF
TONGUE-ACUPUNTURE THERAPY OF PARALYSIS AGITANS
ISSUE DATE: November 12-15, 2000
LAST NAME: Jie-guang
NAME: sun
NATIONALITY: Hong Kong
ADDRESS: Rm204, 2/F, chow yei ching bldg, the university of HK
ABSTRACT: abbreviation
B-2.
TITLE: CLINIC STUDY OF TONGUE-ACUPUNCTURE THERAPY OF PARALYSIS AGITANS
AUTHOR(S): Sun Jie-guang, Sun Xue-ran, Zhang Xiao-bing, Ma Tie-ming
ABSTRACT:
Introduction: Paralysis agitans is also called Parkinson's disease
and the disease of extrapyramidal system, characterized by the agitans
of extremities, muscle rigidity, and hypomotility. This disease
is frequently occurred to men of 50-60 years of age. The cause of
this disease is now clear yet. It is generally considered that this
disease is caused by undue low concentration of dopamine in extrapyramical
system, thus causing degeneration of pallidal globus and black substance.
Methods:
1. General Data
of 105 cases of primary paralysis agitans, 73 men, 32 women; 5:43-50
years old, 66:50-59 years old, 34:over 60-years old; course of disease
6 months-12 years.
2. Observation of curative effect of paralysis agitans
Tongue acupuncture is used, acupuncturing Son's tongue points: Mingzhong,
Tiankui, Ganhe, Chunzhong etc, using the tongue-acupuncture apparatus.
5 days is a course of treatment. The following course of treatment
is after two days. 105 cases of paralysis agitans were treated by
tongue-acupuncture, with total effectiveness 96.19%. 28 cases were
cured, 41 cases were treated with obviously effect, 32 cases were
with effect and only 4 cases were without effect.
Results: To further compare the curative effect of tongue-acupuncture
with that of other acupuncture on paralysis agitans, we take 42
cases of body-acupuncture as control group, comparing the curative
effect of above two groups according to patient's condition and
phases, see table 1. In light of x2 examination, there is not notable
difference between the 2 groups(P>0.05).
Table 1 Comparison between tongue-acupuncture group
and body-Acupuncture group according to patient's condition and
phases
Group Number of cases 1st phase 2nd phase 3rd phase 4th phase
Case % Case % Case % Case %
t.a. 105 25 23.81 51 48.80 22 21.00 7 6.67
b.a. 42 12 28.57 17 40.48 10 23.81 3 7.14
t.a=tongue acupuncture; b.a.=body-acupuncture
The main points for body acupuncture are Baihui, Fengfu, Fengchi,
Yintang, Hegu, Taiching, Taixi, Sanyinjiao, subordinating points
according to symptoms, 5 days is a course of treatment. All cases
take 6 courses of treatment.
Group
Number of
Cases Recovery Obvious effect Effective
Case % Case % Case %
t.a. 101 28 26.67 41 39.05 32 30.48
b.a. 18 0 0 4 9.52 14 33.3
Table 2 Comparison of curative effect between tongue-acupuncture
and body-acupuncture
t.a=tongue acupuncture; b.a.=body-acupuncture
It is clear from table 2, that according to x2 examination, there
is notable difference between above 2 groups in curative effect
(P<0.01), namely the curative effect of tongue acupuncture groups
is far better than that of body acupuncture group.
Conclusion: Tongue acupuncture came out before long,
but got attention from many doctors with its notable curative effect
and obtained satisfied results. The patients usually take L-dopa,
Artane...........the effect of these drugs is reduced with prolongation
of time and the poisonous and side effects are strong. Tongue acupuncture
is easy to operate without any poisonous and side effect, producing
an instant effect and reducing, even dispense with above drugs with
progression of treatment.
Key Words: Paralysis agitans/ Parkinson's disease/ Tongue Acupuncture/
Body Acupuncture
ACUPUNCTURE THESIS
THE FIFTH WORLD CONFERENCE ON ACUPUNCTURE
KS-0104 LOCATION SEOUL
TITLE: CLINICAL RESEARCH
ON TREATING PSEUDO-BULBAR PARALYSIS WITH TONGUE PUNCTURING
ISSUE DATE: November 12-15, 2000
LAST NAME: Jie-guang
NAME: Sun
NATIONALITY: Hong Kong
ADDRESS: Rm204, 2/F, chow yei ching bldg, the university of HK
ABSTRACT: abbreviation
B-3.
TITLE: CLINICAL RESEARCH ON TREATING PSEUDO¡ªBULBAR PARALYSIS WITH
TONGUE PUNCTURING
AUTHOR(S): Sun Jie Guang, Liao Ning Labouring Sun Xue-ran
ABSTRACT:
Introduction:
Adapt tongue puncturing in micro-needling method to treat 125 cases
of pseudo-bulbar paralysis including 89 male, 36 female from 40
to 78 years old of which the course 29 are within 3 months, 96 are
over 3 months. For its original coming on disease, 64 cases are
of multi-coming on cerebral infarction and cerebral atrophy, 45
are pure multi-occuring cerebral infarction, 16 are cerebral atrophy
and other diseases.
Treating method: puncture MingAn, TianGu, GuanZhu, Zhen Jie, TianKui,
RunZe, DiCheng, MingHe, WenAn, TongSu, XuanGen, etc. tongue puncturing
points with small needle. Match the points according to diagnosis,
5 times are one course.
Results & Discussion:
125 cases of pseudo-bulbar paralysis have been treated with tongue
puncturing method, of which 79 cases (63.2%) have been cured completely,
36 are of obvious effect (28.8%), 10 are effective (8%), total effective
rate is 100%. Obviously improve 23 cases of orignal coming-on diseases
(18.4%), 98 cases of it have been improved (78.4%), 4 cases are
ineffective (32%). Within the one course group, there are 57 cases,
of which 19 cases have been recovered (33.33%), 28 of obvious effect
(49.12%), 10 effective (17.54%). In the group with 2 or above 2
courses, there are 68 cases, of which 60 cases have been recovered
(88.24%), 8 cases of obvious effect (11.76%). There exists obvious
difference between the two groups, and the result of 2 or above
2 courses group is better than that of the one-course group (P<0.01).
There are 29 cases whose courses for getting the disease are within
3 months, of which 22 cases have been recovered (75.86%), 6 of obvious
effect (20.69%), 1 effective (3.45%) after treatment. There are
96 cases whose courses getting the disease are above 3 months, of
which 57 cases have been recovered (59.38%), 30 of obvious effect
(31.25%), 9 effective (9.38%) after being treated with the method.
No obvious differences exist between the two groups. That shows
the treating result is not influenced by the course to get pseudo
bulbar paralysis. For the patients who have been punctured for more
than 2 months, 58 cases have been investigated, no recurring appears
within 2 to 4 months; 3 cases show slight symptoms between 5 and
6 months; but the recurring of pseudo¡ªbulbar paralysis is 0. That's
to say, the treating result is rather good.
Conclusions:
Based on holographic theory, the author thinks the channels and
collaterals, vital organs, head and body as well as limbs all have
its related reflecting points or areas on tongue. Observing tongue's
change to diagnose disease is a very key method, so is tongue puncturing
to treat diseases. Pseudo¡ªbulbar paralysis is apoplexy involving
kidney, heart, spleen. While tongue puncturing just treats disease
through clearing channels by adjusting the functions of kidney,
heart and spleen.
Key Words:
Tongue Acupuncture/ Pseudo-Bulbar Paralysis/ Cerebral infarction/
Cerebral atrophy
ACUPUNCTURE THESIS
THE FIFTH WORLD CONFERENCE ON ACUPUNCTURE
KS-0105 LOCATION SEOUL
TITLE: Randomized Control
Trial of using Tongue Acupuncture in children with Autistic Spectrum
Disorder
ISSUE DATE: November 12-15, 2000
LAST NAME: Chun-nei Virginia
NAME: Wong
NATIONALITY: Hong Kong
ADDRESS: Rm112, New Clinical Bldg, Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong
ABSTRACT: abbreviation
A-1.
TITLE: Randomized Control Trial of using Tongue Acupuncture in children
with Autistic Spectrum Disorder
AUTHOR(S): V WONG, JG Sun, XR Sun, W Wong
ABSTRACT:
Introduction: Traditional Chinese Medicine approach to Autism Spectrum
Disorder (ASD) is a more holistic, approach. We aim to improve the
overall functional independence in the children by the effect on
behavior, communication and cognition with an innovative method,
Tongue Acupuncture(TAC).
Methods: TAC was conducted as a double-blind randomized controlled
trial on 30 children with ASD. The children were randomly assigned
to the treatment group with 40 sessions of TAC or control group
with continuing their current behavioral and educational approach
over a course of 8 weeks. We used 7 standardized outcome measure
for comparison. This included: Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS),
Ritvo-Freeman Real Life Scale(RFRLS). Aberrant Behavior Checklist,
Reynell Language Developmental Scale, Preverbal Communication Scale,
functional independence measure for children (WeeFIM) (mobility,
self care and cognition). Parental Stress Index and Clinical Global
Impression Scale(CGIS).
Result: The treatment group had statistically significant improvement
in the following outcome measures: RFRLS: the mean difference in
score ¡¾SD of the treatment group was 0.152¡¾0.192 and control group
was 0.022¡¾0.26(P value = 0.005); WeeFIM: the mean difference in
score of treatment group in mobility was 11.867¡¾8.417 as compared
to control group was 1.0¡¾1.780(P=0.0002);self care domain, the mean
difference in the treatment group was 4.933¡¾6.147 as compared to
control group of 0.5385¡¾1.854(P value=0.0071);and cognition domain,
the mean difference in treatment group was 8.533¡¾6.534, and for
control group was 1.462¡¾2.025(P value=0.0004).
Discussion: Our anecdotal clinical experience for patients with
learning disability and ataxia also showed that there were specific
acupoints on the tongue which improve cognitive function and ataxia
respectively. Improvement in alertness, attention and emotional
state of a child through "starting-up" with TAC to acupoints
rich in neural networking to the frontal cortex through the brainstem
and cerebellum may explain the improvement in the child's awareness
of drooling. Thus, by a mechanism of re-networking of the "brain
systems", plasticity of the brain is evident in various functional
disability.
Conclusion: We observed the overall improvement in intellectual
quotient and communication abilities in these children rather than
just pure behavioral improvement, Even the teachers who were blind
did find improvement in children in terms of behavior, communication
skills and also higher intelligent quotient, have more imaginative-draw
better, more coherence in their composition and writing up of stories,
and become more initiative. In future researches, we still need
to assess other parameters, such as factors contributing to efficacy,
the intermediate and long term efficacy, and whether repeated courses
of TAC are necessary. We are currently trying to document objectively,
using functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) and Positron
Emission Tomography (PET), the specific function of specific acupoints
in normal subjects in order to prove the philosophy of TCM.
Key words: Traditional Chinese Medicine/ Tongue Acupuncture
Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD)/ Children
ACUPUNCTURE THESIS
THE FIFTH WORLD CONFERENCE ON ACUPUNCTURE
KS-0106 LOCATION SEOUL
TITLE: Pilot Study of Efficacy
of Tongue Acupuncture in Neurologically Disabled Children with Severe
ISSUE DATE: November 12-15, 2000
LAST NAME: Chun-nei Virginia
NAME: Wong
NATIONALITY: Hong-Kong
ADDRESS: Rm112, New Clinical Bldg, Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong
ABSTRACT: abbreviation
A-2.
TITLE: Pilot Study of Efficacy of Tongue Acupuncture in Neurologically
Disabled Children with Severe Drooling Problem
AUTHOR(S): V Wong, JG Sun, XR Sun, W Wong
ABSTRACT:
Introduction: Tongue Acupuncture (TAC) is an innovative acupuncture
technique. There are at least 40 acupoints on the tongue which are
linked through the 14 meridians to various organs and viscera. Specific
acupoints were documented to subserve various functional domains
of the human body. Clinical efficacy of acupuncturing the surface
or base of the tongue in specific acupoints proved the efficacy
in improving various functional modalities in patients with chronic
neurological disorders, including pseudobulbar palsy and motor disability
in stroke and cerebral palsy. Our own clinical experience of >20
years with this technique had demonstrated its efficacy and safety.
This study aimed to assess the efficacy of TAC in an objective manner
in children with severe drooling problem.
Methods: We conducted a pilot project as an intent-to-treat study
in a cohort of 10 children (aged 2-18 years) with neurological and/or
cognitive disability having serve drooling problem. These children
had such severe functional disability that they failed to comply
with conventional oral motor stimulation programme or behavior modification
treatment. A course of TAC was performed on a daily ambulatory basis
to 5 acupoints in the tongue (3 on the surface and 2 on the bottom)
for a total of 30 sessions by one of the authors (JGS). The children
were not sedated during the acupuncture treatment. Each acupuncture
lasted for less than 15 seconds. We used standardized outcome measures
of drooling to assess the efficacy of TAC at baseline and after
a course of treatment. The assessors were blinded to any treatment
given.
Results: Pre-and post-treatment data was analyzed with Wilcoxon
matched-pairs signed-rank analysis. Statistically significant improvement
was noted in 3 outcome measures. The mean Visual Analog Scale (VAS)
decreased from 6.6%(pre-TAC) to 4.67(post-TAC) (p=0.002); the mean
Drooling Quotient(DQ) decreased from 14.016%(pre-TAC) to 8.335%(post-TAC)(p=0.0078);
and the mean Drooling Score (DS) decreased from 7.4(pre-TAC) to
4.4 (post-TAC)(p=0.002).
Discussion: Tongue Acupuncture (TAC) is an innovative technique
invented to improve functional disability of patients with chronic
neurological disorders. This pilot study using objective outcome
measures of the severity and frequency of drooling had demonstrated
its efficacy as an alternative treatment for patients with neurological
disability.
Conclusion: Thus, TAC is indicated one of the treatment options
for patients with persistent drooling. TAC can be tried either before
or after failing oromotor stimulation programme; or if the patients
are not suitable candidates for behavioral modification treatment
due to serve cognitive disability. TAC can definitely be tried before
embarking on surgical maneuvers on the salivary glands.
Key words: Drooling,
Cerebral palsy,
Children,
Tongue Acupuncture(TAC),
Traditional Chinese Medicine(TCM)
|